An internal investigation by the Asian Cricket Council (ACC) has revealed that match referee Andy Pycroft displayed partiality during Pakistan’s recent match against India, with evidence of alleged collusion with Indian officials coming to light.
According to sources, the inquiry confirmed that Pycroft violated the code of conduct on multiple occasions during the game.
The report states that at the time of the toss, Pycroft asked Pakistani player Salman Ali Agha to switch off his microphone and listen to him — an action that went against established rules.
Also Read: Asia Cup: ICC rejects PCB’s demand to remove match referee Pycroft
It was further revealed that the referee instructed Salman Agha not to shake hands with India’s Suryakumar Yadav. Under ICC regulations, however, match referees are not authorized to directly issue such instructions to players or captains on the field.
The probe also found that preventing Salman Agha from speaking certain words just 30 seconds before the match began was a “pre-planned” move designed to avoid any potentially controversial reaction.
Additionally, sources claimed that Pycroft shielded Indian batsman Suryakumar Yadav from disciplinary action for using the phrase “Operation Sindoor.” The remark was deliberately overlooked to ensure the player avoided a fine.
Also Read: PCB asks ICC to replace Andy Pycroft as referee for South Africa series
Accepting Pakistan’s request for a change of referee, according to the report, would amount to an acknowledgment that India’s agenda had been exposed.
The revelations have sparked questions about the transparency and impartiality of both the ACC and the ICC, with cricket fans demanding that the full details of the matter be made public.
Earlier today, the International Cricket Council (ICC) officially turned down the Pakistan Cricket Board’s (PCB) demand to remove match referee Andy Pycroft from the ongoing Asia Cup 2025, escalating tensions between the cricketing body and Pakistan, sources said.
ICC rejects PCB’s request
They said that on Tuesday, the ICC formally rejected the PCB’s request to replace Pycroft. The decision was conveyed to the PCB a day earlier and confirmed in an official letter. Sources say that Pakistan will withdraw from Asia Cup if the PCB's demand is not met.
The PCB had accused Pycroft of violating the ICC Code of Conduct and the Spirit of Cricket during Pakistan’s group-stage clash against India. PCB chairman Mohsin Naqvi, who also heads the Asian Cricket Council (ACC), publicly demanded Pycroft’s removal, calling it a breach of cricketing protocol.
Handshake controversy
The controversy erupted during the toss on September 14, when Pycroft reportedly told Pakistan captain Salman Ali Agha not to shake hands with India’s skipper Suryakumar Yadav. This angered the PCB, which saw the move as biased.
Also Read: Pakistan threaten Asia Cup boycott over referee controversy
However, the ICC allegedly clarified that Pycroft was simply following ACC officials’ instructions. The council had decided there would be no handshakes at the toss, and Pycroft was only relaying that directive. ICC dismissed the suggestion that he acted on India’s behalf, the sources said.
Post-match drama
Tensions deepened after India’s victory, when players Suryakumar Yadav and Shivam Dube rushed off the field without handshakes. While it initially appeared that both teams avoided the gesture, Pakistan’s lineup, led by captain Agha and coach Mike Hesson, later approached India’s dressing room to complete the tradition.
Also Read: Ind vs Pak handshake row: PCB seeks referee Andy Pycroft’s removal
The Indian side, however, shut their dressing room door, rejecting the customary post-match handshakes. The incident further inflamed Pakistan’s frustration, leading to demands for Pycroft’s removal.
Pakistan’s strong protest
PCB sources confirmed that Pakistan threatened to boycott their remaining matches in the ongoing Asia Cup tournament if Pycroft remains match referee. Officials have already begun consultations within the board and with the ACC to address the situation.
Also Read: PCB chief slams India’s refusal to shake hands after Asia Cup clash
Reports suggest that if Pakistan forfeits Thursday’s match in Dubai, UAE would automatically progress in the tournament, knocking Pakistan out of the Asia Cup 2025. Currently, both teams are tied on two points in Group A.
ICC’s stand
Despite Pakistan’s tough stance, the ICC has allegedly reaffirmed that Pycroft will continue officiating in the Asia Cup, including Pakistan’s next game against the UAE. The governing body emphasized that match officials are appointed by the ICC in coordination with the ACC and that Pycroft’s role is not under dispute.
On Monday, the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) formally requested the International Cricket Council (ICC) not to assign Andy Pycroft as the match referee for the upcoming home series against South Africa scheduled in October.
