Welcome to SAMAA TV
 
SAMAA SMS News Alerts
 
COAS terms media reports on Sharifs meeting were based on assumptions: COAS         Sri Lanka lose Welegedara for Champions Trophy         ECP issues notification of 808 successful MNAs, MPAs         PML-N’s Aziz Abro joins PPP         We need to take Pakistan out of problems: Nawaz Sharif         Afghanistan's Karzai gives India military equipment 'wish list'         Zardari says Sino-Pak relationship is corner stone of foreign policy         Cricket: Pakistan, Ireland to meet in Dublin Thursday         Temperature rises to 48 degrees centigrade in Sindh, Punjab cities         Zardari meets Nawaz at luncheon for Chinese PM         Target killer nabbed in Karachi         Iran's Ahmadinejad says will challenge ally's ban from election         Millions falling into poverty in recession-racked Italy: report         SHC stops PTI victory notification in PS-93         Sreesanth says did not indulge in spot-fixing         Mobile phone service restored in Islamabad, Pindi         Militants release seven Egyptians kidnapped in Sinai         Musharraf bail plea rejected in judges detention case         SC puts off Altaf speech case hearing for one week         Supreme Court revokes transfers and postings by caretaker govt         India test fires supersonic cruise missile         Underdogs Australia ready for Ashes scrap, says Clarke         North Korea sends top Kim Jong-un aide to Beijing         Whole neighborhoods razed by Oklahoma tornado as rescue efforts continue         Chinese PM arrives in Islamabad amid warm welcome         Death toll rises to 28 in Freeport Indonesia mine accident         Prominent lawyer gunned down in Lahore         Cellular services will remain suspended in Islamabad, Pindi today         PTI chief Imran Khan discharged from hospital         Japan considers resuming talks with North Korea         Ten-party alliance’s strike today in Sindh against riggings         Asian stocks cheered by Fed reassurance, yen awaits Bank of Japan         Congolese army, rebels clash for a second day, 19 dead         Miliband says Google tax behaviour 'wrong'         Iran bars candidates for presidential election         Abducted ex-AG Balochistan Salahuddin recovered         Dollar dips vs euro before Bernanke testimony; yen weakens         Chinese PM to arrive in Islamabad on 2-day visit today         Altaf dissolves MQM’s Tanzimi Committee in Karachi         Attacks in Iraq kill over 40, sectarian tensions high         Murray pulls out of French Open through injury        
Iran nuclear concession would test big power unity
Wednesday, May 16, 2012 5:08:14 PM | Comments (0)
Iran nuclear concession would test big power unity

LONDON/VIENNA: Facing an imminent toughening of sanctions, Iran is hinting at a readiness to give some ground in its long nuclear stand-off with world powers, but any flexibility could split their ranks and lead to protracted uncertainty about how to respond.

The stakes are high, for the longer the impasse goes on, the closer Iran will get to the technological threshold of capability to develop atomic bombs, raising the odds of last-ditch Israeli military strikes on its arch-foe and the risk of a new Middle East war a troubled global economy cannot afford.

A succession of optimistic statements by Iranian officials and academics has raised speculation that Tehran may offer concessions to its six main negotiating partners in talks scheduled for May 23 in Baghdad, a move that could ease regional tensions and soothe fears of a fresh spike in oil prices.

Such an offer would also be closely studied by Israel, which has threatened to use force to destroy nuclear installations the Islamic Republic says are purely civilian in nature but the West suspects are geared to gaining a weapons capability.

Any talk of a diplomatic breakthrough, though, is almost certainly premature.

Whatever concrete gestures are tabled by Iran would test anew the cohesiveness of joint Western, Russian and Chinese efforts to prevent an Iranian atom bomb capability, and might simply lead to months of inconclusive consultations among its interlocutors about how to answer Tehran's move, analysts say.

Differences in how best to match an Iranian offer - for example by suspending some sanctions in return for Iran shelving enrichment of uranium to 20 percent purity, a level that worries U.N. nuclear experts - could snag efforts to turn any such initiative into meaningful movement towards negotiations.

"Don't expect a 'Kumbaya' (celebratory) moment. It's going to be a poker play" between Iran and the major powers, French analyst Bruno Tertrais said. "I would be surprised if what happens in Baghdad was more than an agreement on interim steps."

ISOLATION

There is "no doubt " that Iran's policy would be to split the six, known as the P5+1, says Dennis Ross, until November a chief Middle East strategy adviser at the White House.

"I also have no doubt that they probably will put something on the table that they think will be attractive to some of the members of the P5+1," Ross told an audience at the Bipartisan Policy Center in Washington.

He said one such move could be Iranian assurances on a halt to stockpiling of 20 percent enriched uranium.

That level, well beyond the 5 percent of fissile purity suitable for running civilian nuclear power plants, is intended only to replenish the fuel stocks of a medical isotope reactor, Iran says. But it also moves Iran farther down the road towards the highly enriched grade of uranium usable in bombs.

One Western government assessment is that it would take Iran two to three years to manufacture a usable nuclear weapon in the event that authorities in Tehran decided to attempt that task.

Analysts and some diplomats have said Iran and the global powers must compromise for any chance of a long-term settlement, suggesting Tehran could be allowed to continue limited low-level enrichment if it accepts more intrusive U.N. inspections.

But Iran has often managed to limit its diplomatic and economic isolation by sowing rifts among the six states spearheading international efforts to rein in Iran's nuclear programme, leading to a watering-down of U.N. sanctions.

Western analysts are on alert for any new such gambit now.

A united front among Russia, China, the United States, France, Germany and Britain is the most powerful leverage the outside world has in ensuring Iranian compliance with international safeguards intended to curb the proliferation of nuclear weapons, Western analysts say.

And yet that unity has always been fragile.

Russia and China, which both have strong trade ties to Iran, have supported four rounds of U.N. sanctions imposed since 2006 on Iran over its refusal to suspend enrichment-related activity and grant unfettered U.N. inspections to resolve suspicions of military dimensions to its nuclear programme.

But Moscow and Beijing criticised the United States and the European Union last year for meting out extra unilateral sanctions against Iran. Russia as made clear its opposition to any further U.N. Security Council measures against Tehran.

"I think P5+1 will have significant problems whenever it comes to Iran actually moving and how they respond," a European diplomat told Reuters. "At this moment in time it is easy and nothing has been promised by Iran ... but I think it will become very difficult and very tense on the P5+1 side once they have to start reacting to an Iranian step."

"EARLY TEST OF UNITY"

Mark Fitzpatrick of London's International Institute for Strategic Studies said an Iranian demand for an easing of sanctions in return for its concessions "will present an early test of P5+1 unity. For the West, any lifting of sanctions would require significant limitations on the enrichment programme."

There is little debate about what may be encouraging Iran to indicate new flexibility: Iran, analysts say, wishes to stave off the planned July 1 start to a European Union ban on imports of Iranian oil, a significant measure since the EU takes a fifth of the country's petroleum shipments.

But there is plenty of speculation about the extent to which Russia and China are prepared to reward any Iranian shift.

Shashank Joshi of the Royal United Services Institute said divergence between Russia and China and its other partners would likely emerge on the price the world should demand for dropping the insistence, enshrined in the Security Council resolutions, that Iran cease any enrichment whatsoever.

He said the United States would want to see the dismantling of an enrichment plant buried deep under a mountain at Fordow south of Tehran, the Iranian nuclear site best sheltered from any possible air strike.

"The Russians and Chinese may recognise that this is unlikely, and may accept Iranian offers short of this," he said.

"So we should expect to see Iran attempt to split the Russians and Chinese from the others by offering something concrete and significant, but short of dismantlement."

Tehran has ruled out closing the bunkered Fordow site.

SIGNS OF NEW IRANIAN APPROACH

Diplomats and analysts say an agreement is still far off, but the signs are growing that Iran's leaders are changing their approach and preparing public opinion for a potential shift.

Tehran's former chief nuclear negotiator, Hossein Mousavian, now a visiting scholar at Princeton University in the United States, said last month Iran and major nations had a "historic opportunity" to settle their decade-old nuclear dispute.

On May 2, Deputy Foreign Minister Mohammad Mahdi Akhondzadehhe said in a speech in Vienna: "We continue to be optimistic about upcoming negotiations."

In April, Foreign Minister Ali Akbar Salehi said Iran was "ready to resolve all issues very quickly and simply". AGENCIES

 
 
Watch SAMAA TV Live
IEA report raises oil demand but warns of Iran risk
Iran wins release of Turkish journalists in Syria
Suicide bomber, car bombs hit Iraq security forces
Measles kills 12 kids in tribal areas in 3 weeks
IAEA talks at Iran mission in Vienna to resume Tuesday
Iranian rapper draws Shi'ite wrath, death bounty
Iran upbeat on U.N. nuclear talks, diplomats skeptical
Iran says Saudi-Bahrain union plan deepens crisis
COAS terms media reports on Sharifs meeting were based on assumptions: COAS
Sri Lanka lose Welegedara for Champions Trophy
ECP issues notification of 808 successful MNAs, MPAs
PML-N’s Aziz Abro joins PPP
We need to take Pakistan out of problems: Nawaz Sharif
 
 
 
Post Your Comments
Note: SAMAA TV values your opinions and encourages you to add a comment to this discussion. Please don't be offended if we edit and/or remove questionable, off topic comments; SAMAA TV is not responsible for user comments.
Name:
 
Email:
 
 Leave a Comment:
 
Security Code:
 
 
User Comments
No comment(s) found.
 
     
SAMAA TV
UPDATES WITH
follow us on facebook
follow us on twitter
follow us on youtube
isamaa
subscribe for samaa email news alerts
samaa sms alert
samaa rss